Something Has To Give: A Care Home Inquiry
by
Lydia Hughes
November 17, 2026
Featured in The Work Ahead (#28)
Lydia Hughes reflects on her time working in a rural care home.
inquiry
Something Has To Give: A Care Home Inquiry
by
Lydia Hughes
/
Nov. 17, 2026
in
The Work Ahead
(#28)
Lydia Hughes reflects on her time working in a rural care home.
Care homes have an eerie feeling about them. They are designed, as much as possible, to look like homes. In the lounge there is a fake fireplace, with arm chairs gathered round it. However, it is lit by a strong white overhead light and a glowing green emergency exit sign hung over the door. The chairs are all wipe clean, adding to the clinical feel. A bowl of fake fruit sits in the middle of the coffee table. Signs hung by string line the walls, with fairly meaningless statements on them, “home is where the heart is.”
Care homes are surrounded by mystery. Despite seeing them in every town and city in Britain, it’s quite likely most people will have never been inside one. If you walk past one on the street it’s hard to get a look in, the windows are frosted. The entrance is fortified with two sets of doors, needing codes to get in.
Care sits in the public imagination only in extremes. We hear the care sector is in crisis, on the brink of collapse. Many people spend their lives telling their kids they don’t want to end up in a care home. When care workers appear on our screens, it is almost exclusively through two caricatures: the role of a nasty, abusive care worker in an exposé documentary, titled something like Undercover Care: The Abuse Exposed. Or as the sacrificial, kind angel who we all applauded on our doorsteps during COVID lockdowns. These images conceal far more than they reveal. The myth of the saint makes it easy to pay workers in gratitude instead of proper wages. The myth of the monster blames individual workers for the sector’s systemic decay.
To look past this spectacle requires understanding more about the lives of 1.5 million workers working in adult social care in England. It means taking seriously the most commonly held job title for women in Britain: care worker. I’ve started this inquiry at a place where official reporting stops: on the care home floor. Little reporting on the “care crisis” discusses what care work actually is, the mechanics of it. Yet in these daily realities of shift lies the basis of the exploitation and the power needed to overturn it.
This task is especially urgent right now. For the first time in a long time (maybe ever?), there seems to be quite significant political will to change things. Andy Burnham, as the new Prime Minister, has vowed to fix the social care system. The Adult Social Care Negotiating Body is being set up in 2027 to introduce sector-wide collective bargaining through Fair Pay Agreements. This is supposedly backed by an extra £500 million in funding from the government. This momentum is exciting.
Care workers are also taking unprecedented levels of industrial action. In issue 25, Hammering the Sky, workers involved in this wave of struggle detailed how they organised and took action.1 What follows is the start of an inquiry that aims to build on this movement and spread it to every care home in Britain. I detail what working in a care home is like. Firstly, through describing what life in a care home looks like, then the bodily mechanics of the job and how they are defined by understaffing. I go into detail on how it’s managed, from above through an app and then by workers on the care home floor. Then I try to draw some conclusions on the challenges to building solidarity in care, none of which are insurmountable. We know not every care home is the same. So if you want to write about your experience of care work, get in touch with Notes from Below.
Living and working in a care home
The “floor”, as we call it, is centred around a lounge and a dining room. Beige, carpeted corridors lined with boxy bedrooms meet there. Some bedrooms are bursting with things, seemingly the whole contents of the residents’ previous homes. Others are depressingly simple, with only a few photos or items of clothing. This layout ensures all residents don’t have a long walk to the lounge. It is mostly designed, however, to make workers more efficient.
In the centre are the store rooms for staff: for equipment, a sluice room and a meds storage room. With this configuration you can minimise your time grabbing equipment or disposing of dirty pads and clothes, before speed walking to the next resident’s room. This also allows for you to easily have eyes on all the residents, reducing the time it takes to do your regular checks on residents who are prone to go missing or have falls. Despite this convenient setup, I still walk at least 6km in steps up and down these short corridors in a shift.
Most residents have TVs in their rooms, size in inches often correlated to their class positions. Volumes are turned up very high to compensate for hearing loss, and are playing the same ITV day time drama. The plots to these dramas turn up later in resident’s dementia-related paranoid moments. I’m touched when Rick takes it on himself to protect me from a spy who has infiltrated the home - “We will air lift you out of here in T minus 20 minutes!”
Combined with the TV in the lounge, this creates a tinny surround sound of noise. This becomes easier to shut out once you’re used to it. You do, however, have to tune into the sounds of the bell system. It looks like it’s from the 80s, despite the home only being built in the 2000s. Each resident has the ability to ring the bell in their room to summon you, either through a button or through a mat that indicates a resident has fallen or stood up. These bells ring constantly, demanding your scarce attention. Even when I’m not on shift I hear phantom bells.
The heat is an aspect I quite like in winter, but less so in summer. Even when it’s -1 degrees outside, the home is heated to a hot 26 degrees. No matter how cold your bus ride is, you know you’re going to be toasty all day. At more hectic moments, when I’m rushing back and forth between residents, I get so hot that I’m sweating in my bright, polyester uniform. I sneak off to use the wall mounted temperature taker, pushing my forehead to it. I’m often convinced that I have a fever, but every time it was a normal 37 degrees.
The corridors have that very specific smell of industrial laundry. The one laundry assistant works flat out washing and drying endless sheets, towels, flannels and clothes. Some rooms, often of those who are well cared for by their relatives, smell like powdery talcum powder and old lady perfume. Whereas others have a thick smell of urine, hinting at constant overflowing pads that get soaked into the carpet.
The work of care
The core tasks of the role are things that most women were taught to do growing up. In that way it is a collection of all the most feminised jobs. You plate up and serve lunch and tea. You constantly fill up, run and unpack the dishwasher. You regularly change sheets and towels in resident’s rooms. You clean up after residents in their rooms and the common areas.
However, you are also expected to do “personal care.” This was the bit of the job that I was most nervous about. I had changed my niece’s nappy, but didn’t have the experience of caring for an elderly relative that many people who work in care have had. On my first shadow shift, when I had only observed one pad change before, I was shocked when the carer asked me if I wanted to have a go. Up until this point my training had only consisted of a day of mindlessly clicking through e-learnings.
In the small en suite bathroom, the other carer and I hovered around Susan as she passed a bowel movement on the toilet. We all made unselfconscious comfortable small talk as I slipped on blue medical gloves. “How’s your daughter? Oh, on holiday! How nice!” I supported the resident up from the toilet, with her hands resting on her frame and mine on her back. In that position we got into a rhythm. I passed her toilet paper to wipe her front. Then I wiped the back, keeping going until it came back clean. We repeated this dance with a wet flannel and then a towel. The resident patiently talked me through it, “too cold” and “get up in there.” The carer instructed me where to put the cream, a small amount where her leg meets her groin and where the pad will rub at the back. Finally, I bent down to lift up the new incontinence pad, pulling it up to a secure position and almost lifting the light woman off the ground.
This first slightly awkward experience of personal care was soon behind me. Before long I was doing the resident’s whole morning and evening personal care routines myself (the person I was supposed to shadow on my second shift never turned up). These routines became well rehearsed and quick. The images on care home websites or in brochures will have you believing that the majority of a care worker’s job involves holding the hands of elderly people and laughing with them. However, in reality the work is quite mechanical.
The big task of getting all the residents on your floor out of bed, washed, dressed and having eaten, and then undressed, washed and into bed must be done with an efficiency that can leave little time for caring for people in an emotional sense. Residents are either singles (requiring one carer for personal care), doubles (two) or independents (in theory can do their own). Doubles are usually lifted from chairs to wheelchairs, to toilets, to beds using mechanical hoists. As carers we work in sync, passing pads and flannels back and forth, quickly completing the tasks of personal care before moving on to the next residents. Singles are often harder. With no hoist to mechanise the process, you have to work slowly with a resident to maneuver them onto the toilet or in a position to clean them, when their mind or body make this a challenge.
This daily work is defined by a severe understaffing. The pace at which the work must be done doesn’t allow for much beyond these most basic reproductive tasks. A couple of extra workers on shift would allow personal care to be done at a slower pace, something that would hugely benefit residents with Parkinson’s, for example. It could be done to a better quality too, with less time spent with residents sitting in wet pads and residents being able to go to the toilet when they ask. However, to reach the point that care workers have the headspace to be able to complete the mechanical tasks to a high standard and provide the more emotional care, that requires a total rewiring of the role.
How the work is managed
I’m sure it varies from home to home, but in general I’ve found that managers are quite hands off. They seem to be endlessly busy in their offices, with walls lined with framed certificates for things like “excellence in care.” Work is instead loosely supervised by your senior carers. How much they engage with the floor varies a lot based on personality, but mostly it is about their level of burnout. Senior carers also have a huge workload, often doing five medication rounds a day and struggling to keep up with the paperwork.
Management is increasingly done through an app. This digitisation of care records is a pretty recent phenomenon. Some homes still use pen and paper, but the majority made the switch two years ago due to government initiatives like the Adult Social Care Technology Fund. Every morning routine, evening routine and time on the toilet are inputted on smart phones that we have to keep in our pockets at all times. Extra information is needed on some residents: a wellbeing check every half an hour, how many milliliters they have drunk, what they had for breakfast/lunch/tea etc. Should you put your phone down for a minute it’s likely a diligent resident with dementia, who was a cleaner in their previous life, will come along and tidy it away.
Senior carers are put under pressure to make sure carers resolve all the “interactions” in a shift. This creates a pressure to input data, even if to say you haven’t done the interaction (e.g. applied a cream), rather than to actually do the task. It’s unclear how much of this huge quantity of data is being used by managers. Managers issue almost daily commands through the app’s messaging function that seem to be based on data from the back end. “Maggie hasn’t had a bath in 30 days. Bath her today. This is unacceptable :)” These out of context commands make me so angry. Why are you commanding me to do more, when I’m already at my limit? When I complained to other workers, they just shrugged and said to just ignore it like everyone else does. I came to understand this form of management as performative compliance.2 When the Care Quality Commission comes round to inspect they can say they’ve done their due diligence, and push the blame onto us without hiring more carers to get the task done.
Where efficiency means having extra time to rest your feet and finish your digital paperwork, it’s highly prized amongst care workers. Carers assess new carers work performance, teaching them the “tricks of the trade” and guiding them when they aren’t doing it the fastest way. For my first two months in care, everyone was perfectly nice to me but didn’t really bother to get to know me or teach me the tricks. This made sense. Many people come and go. If you’ve worked there for 10 years or more you’ve probably met dozens of workers who haven’t stayed more than a few weeks. Everything changed at the two month point. That’s when I felt I was brought into the group.
Stan Weir,3 a ‘blue-collar intellectual’, had an analysis of this kind of informal working group - the ‘team which works together daily in face-to-face communication with one another [is] a family at work torn by hate and love, conflict and common interest’. Weir writes that it is these informal work groups, self-selecting, that do the most disciplining of one another as workers: an informal work group ‘has a naturally selected leadership, makes decisions in the immediate work area, and can affect the flow of production’. When new carers aren’t up to scratch the group discusses the issue and often speaks to the carer. At my three-month review, all the manager said was, “I’ve heard good things.” No printed off report from the app, or assessment of my work rate. The manager had no idea how I was performing according to the metrics I thought I was being measured against; they relied entirely on the network of trusted, experienced workers.
In reality, the person running the floor isn’t the manager hiding in the office - it’s the carers who have been on the floor day after day and know every resident by heart. The flow of work on a shift is more likely to be directed by another carer who everyone trusts, than by a manager. This carer isn’t necessarily the person who has worked in care the longest, but it’s the person who has the most knowledge of these specific residents in this home. This person knows that Sally always needs a pad change straight after tea, but will call every night to be put to bed at 7pm on the dot, that Susan will only eat one ham sandwich on brown and one cheese sandwich on white, that Sarah takes medication at 9pm and needs to be taken to the toilet before it kicks in. Despite not being in any formal position of power, and earning no extra money, this leader maps out an entire shift’s complex logistics in their heads. They dictate in what order residents are going to be “done” and rattle off orders, ones I was glad to receive.
Stan Weir recognised these informal work groups for the power that they had. A group that organises the work, when it happens, how it happens and if it happens, has huge power. Currently informal work groups in care are a site of internal conflict. When you’re exhausted and overworked and your coworker goes on a cigarette break that you feel is a few minutes too long it’s easy for it to erupt. Tensions often build up. Instead of being turned against management, carers turn on each other. However, this form of organisation could be used differently, to fight for a better care system.
Prospects for organising
I often find when people talk about barriers to organising it is demotivating, so I’ve been hesitant to write about it. I think there are a lot of opportunities for organising, that I’ve mentioned above. But I hope to develop a shared understanding of what it will take to successfully organise the whole care sector.
To be able to do the job long term you need to reach a level of desensitisation and normalisation. I felt it happen in real time to myself. When I first started work in the care sector I was shocked at the routine level of neglect that was accepted. It wasn’t the shocking things you see in documentaries. It was instead how low the level of care is that our society thinks is acceptable. Residents were fed, washed(ish) and got out of bed, enough to warrant a “good” CQC inspection. But their quality of life was so far from what I would want for myself or anyone else. Instead of being able to give autonomy back to those whose age or health had taken it away, the understaffing instead compounded the problem. Residents waited in long (mental) queues to go to the bathroom, sitting for periods of time in wet pads. Residents were mentally distressed by the situation, bored, frustrated and in pain that they regularly shouted out, “HELP ME, HELP ME, HELP ME”, or fought each other, sometimes physically.
Something has to give. As a currently politically unorganised force, no serious collective pressure is being applied upwards on managers to improve the situation. Instead pressure is applied on residents. Residents see you as the face of this systemic neglect. They reach out to you for some form of connection, calling to you from their rooms to have a chat but you know that you have to walk past, in a rush to get to a resident with a more urgent physical need. Carers role then becomes one of disciplinarian, having to discipline residents to ask for less because there isn’t the time to help.
Being witness to this, and being forced to be complicit in it, is hard. Carers who can’t make some kind of peace with the situation tend to leave. They burn themselves out by trying to overcompensate, or find it too physically/emotionally difficult. To be there every day and then go back again tomorrow, you have to become somewhat desensitised to the resident’s discomfort. It becomes a fact of life, and not one that can be changed. This normalisation makes it difficult to switch to an organising mindset. Once you start seeing all the things that are wrong, it makes it harder and harder to go back.
Quite understandably, carers are very sceptical that things would ever get better. Not unlike many people in society, those who have worked in care for decades, have witnessed things getting progressively worse and worse. There is a need for a powerful vision of what care homes could look like, rooted in a worker and resident perspective.
With the intense emotional pressures of the job, I also found a positivity trap. When I started I asked what people thought of the work and what issues they are facing at the moment. Quickly I found that people were unreceptive. Carers who complained too much were labelled as having a “bad attitude.” Complaints about the work should be music to any trade unionist’s ears. But when I worked with people who liked to complain, I felt drained by it. The shift felt longer, my legs heavier and the work never-ending. The carers that were respected and listened to, and that everyone wanted to work with, were those that brought a jolly positivity. This challenge can definitely be overcome, but perhaps need a rethinking of the ways unions teach people to organise.
The situation of the Health and Care Worker visa is also one to take seriously. Workers on the visa document their difficulties thoroughly in the piece Caring on a Visa (issue 25), and in a response piece published in this issue, I Came to Care, But I Was Broken By the System. Employers threaten workers with taking away their visa if they speak up, which makes organising difficult. In my organising with the Pan African Workers Association I’ve seen that these barriers aren’t immovable and great organising work is happening.
The work ahead
It’s hard to write a nuanced account of working in care. It’s easy to say it’s all bad, and easier to say that it’s beautiful, special or meaningful. Despite being emotionally incredibly difficult, it is also probably my favourite job I’ve ever done. There is satisfaction in doing even the very most basic caring work for people who need it. It also makes it possible to imagine how care homes could be organised in another way. There is a world in which money destined for wars, or an offshore private equity bank account, goes to care homes. We could take pride in giving high quality care in a way that doesn’t break our backs. Personal care could happen slowly and calmly, when residents want and on their own terms. Care homes could be places people no longer dread moving to, that no one warns their kids never to stick them in one. It should be possible for residents in every care home, no matter their personal wealth, to live happy, complete lives. And for care workers to do the same.
There is a clear opening for adult social care organising. Although imperfect, big unions are taking social care organising seriously for the first time. Migrant care workers are self organising through new formations, such as the Pan African Workers’ Association. There is an opening for workers and residents to join forces to improve this situation for everyone. Now we need to wrestle with how to build the collective power in each 16,000+ care homes necessary to make the change we need to see.
-
See Editorial: Left in Our Care in Issue 25: Hammering the Sky for a detailed list. ↩
-
See Joe Greener’s writing on working in a collapsing care home chain. ↩
-
See Stan Weir’s The Informal Work Group. ↩
Featured in The Work Ahead (#28)
author
Lydia Hughes
Subscribe to Notes from Below
Subscribe now to Notes from Below, and get our print issues sent to your front door three times a year. For every subscriber, we’re also able to print a load of free copies to hand out in workplaces, neighbourhoods, prisons and picket lines. Can you subscribe now and support us in spreading Marxist ideas in the workplace?
Read next
Too Hot to Drive, Just Right To Fight
by
An anonymous bus driver
/
July 15, 2026
