Throughout my very accelerated introduction to trade unionism, I have concluded that we learn more from defeat than from victory. To have experienced both, within the space of a year, feels like an achievement itself. In August of 2025, we became the first hotel workers in Britain to take strike action in 50 years, demanding the living wage, applied equally, and for a pay disparity between us workers for the same company in another city to be addressed. After three weeks of continuous picketing, we achieved a pay rise, addressed the disparity, including backdated pay for the period in which the disparity existed. We were also offered an end to zero-hour contracts. We were not offered, crucially, the living wage, applied equally regardless of age, or union recognition. So we went back to work to rebuild.

Organising within my department was aided by the success and promises of our August victory. We had disappeared for 3 weeks, and we had returned triumphant, key demands met, hearts spurred on, pockets heavier. A coworker of mine said to me once we were back, “I really don’t know why I didn’t come out the first time. I don’t know what the worst I was expecting was!”

At this point, a year on from our initial strike action, it’s hard not to feel that our second strike, from November to April, was an answer to their question. Off the back of three sunny weeks in August, bookended by tangible triumph, organising was an easy sell. But the 6 months of cold and snow, strikebreaking and scabbing, real blows and real inaction from what felt sometimes like all parties involved - is a much harder thing to ask someone to be a part of.

Being on strike for 6 months, continuously, with daily pickets, does funny things to your psyche. Watching, from outside, the inner workings of the hotel like the bisection of a doll’s house, the warm light disguising the disorganisation your absence has created. You see unfamiliar faces through the glass and realise that the company, pleading economic restraints as the reason for non-negotiation, suddenly finds some spare cash, for your job has been filled temporarily by a teenager from England, whose flight from Nottingham, bedroom, meals, and spending money were paid, for months at a time, by the company from whom you are asking for 15 pence more an hour.

So you up the ante. You arrive before dawn and play the most irritating music you can think of - and though you are half asleep you are thrilled when the lights of the windows snap on and raging heads appear, illuminated, shouting abuse at you. You dance.

Other days though, miserable February afternoons, a car pulls over, and a man with a big beard claims he is an undercover police officer. On this occasion, you are a group of nearly all young women; he tells you he has been watching you. In your alarm, you forget to record him, because all the other police officers have been relatively amicable, even sheepish, have introduced themselves, and allowed you to get their badge numbers. Sure, they have been called to your peaceful, lawful picket line 13 times - but they have not sat in an unmarked car across the road from you and “watched.” You complain to Police Scotland; they do not reply.

You and your colleagues are harassed, threatened, and assaulted on the picket line, often by guests at the hotel. The General Manager seems to forget their duty of care to you, and does nothing in response to these events, refusing even to cut off guests at the bar. Of course, what is the threat of violence to staff when compared with the potential sale of some overpriced pints?

While shivering in the pouring rain, wearing hats, gloves, and hi-vis, you watch the coworkers you used to laugh with pull down the blinds of the restaurant to conceal you and your slogans from the patrons enjoying their Sunday roasts. This textbook alienation is management’s best bargaining strategy. They cannot convince you that you are wrong, but they can convince you that you are alone. Through the othering of you, your demands too are made ludicrous to the other staff. You doubt yourself. Obviously, it was always corporate nonsense, but this company once welcomed you to its “family,” and now it treats you with cruel, unwavering recalcitrance. Somehow, that was the worst bit of the second strike, the fact that the CEO and upper management refused to negotiate whatsoever. I had heard how they knocked back attempts to get our key demands in the first strike, but that had still been a conversation, at which a few of the workers themselves were present.

Now, you and your colleagues have been placed under investigation, your ability questioned - you are selfish, freakish, skivers with student politics and a bad work ethic. Guests avoid you on your way into the building. Regular customers avert their eyes. You are their personal trainer, their favourite barista, their best bartender, yet they are too uncomfortable in their guilt to speak to you and too comfortable in their routine to change it. And yet, everyone I spoke to agreed with what we were asking for. Many were shocked by the numbers, others outraged on principle. Taken outside the context of conversation between worker and boss, our demands cannot sound anything more than moderate. Only a brain washed by greed and cruelty would refuse to even discuss them.

Neoliberalism, in its insidiousness, makes us into the product and the entrepreneur; the boss and the subordinate. We are tricked into misunderstanding our lack of choice as a freedom we just aren’t utilising. People claim there’s no use in organising hospitality: “I won’t be in this place much longer,” before they look up, and one summer has turned into eight. Similarly, people sometimes asked us, “If it’s so bad, why not just get another job?” The question suits only the CEOs and the middle managers with appetites for boots. It assumes the workplace, which should be as valued as any other, as a site for escape. It is degrading. It imagines exploitation as a private inconvenience instead of a social relation. Someone, after all, will still be pulling pints, stripping beds and cleaning bathrooms. The only question is who. The answer, more often than not, is those with the fewest choices.

We did not strike because we wanted different jobs; we went on strike because we wanted this one to be better, for ourselves and for everyone who would clock in after us. Capitalism depends upon workers treating every indignity as an individual issue to be endured or fled, and hospitality has never possessed the industrial density that gives other sectors their bargaining power. Organisation, as we have learnt, is a constant process, as much of a revolving door as the turnover of the job itself. There is a constant sense of starting from scratch, again and again. Our strike proved, I hope, that it was nonetheless possible.

Yet, this year has taken a toll. Nearly everyone who carried the greatest responsibility has had to take a step back in one way or another. It is difficult not to feel the weight of defeat alongside the pride of what we achieved. The challenge can feel insurmountable - to inculcate within workers an entitlement to respect that they have never known within the sector - ask them to envision it, empower them to ask for it - while knowing the potential for abject denial from the company. It is easier to be complacent.

This sense of powerlessness was abated in part due to my visit to the Kimpton Clocktower Hotel picket line (whose writing also features in this issue). In the first instance, they have a number of external factors on their side - the location, far more central than our hotel, on one of the busiest crossroads in Manchester; the weather, much more reminiscent of our sun-dappled August picket lines. In the second - they had simply made a number of better choices from the start. They were not out continuously, and crucially, they did not have pickets every day (the fact that we did this was both ludicrous and impressive, I think, definitely not something I recommend but was commendable, I suppose, as a feat).

Crucially, their strike revolves around the desire for union recognition - formal recognition of a workplace union that already exists, that is evident in the care and support these young people have for one another. In our case, the establishment of a workplace union has had to come retroactively. In comparison, our strike felt to me like a collection of necessary, but disparate demands. In our case, it was hard not to feel as though we had the least autonomy of any party involved. The Company, of course, dangling the prospect of negotiation over our heads, frequently felt like the most powerful actor. But mistakes, decisions, and inaction taken by the Union, while inevitable to an extent, also proved a significant hindrance. Indeed, conceptualising ‘the union’ as not an external body of bureaucrats but as us, the workers, and us alone, is something we are still realising. Kimpton are miles ahead of us on this front; they are fighting for the recognition of what they have already built. It felt very much, watching them, that they had the power in their hands.

It was genuinely inspiring. And I was also proud to know that the sacrifices that we made, the instability we had subjected ourselves to, and the friendships that we lost, had not been a worthless, solitary act of defiance or some failed experiment, but a demonstrable part of something now larger than ourselves. At an event a few months after going back to work, I was asked in a Q&A a really lovely question: “What keeps you going? What keeps you wanting to organise?” It had been a difficult day, so without thinking, I just said, “Spite.”

This got a lot of laughs, which hadn’t really been my intention. Although my knee-jerk reaction certainly speaks to its authenticity, it’s not the whole truth. Spite will get you out of bed for a 6 am picket, and it will keep you warm for an hour or two, but it won’t keep you going for a year. What I said next, although I suspect I may have lost them at that point, was more accurate: I have met some truly amazing people through this job and through getting involved in trade unionism. I want the best for them and the best for every other hotel and hospitality worker in this city. We all deserve the basic dignity that The Company, and others, so consistently deny, and we are all capable of taking that power into our own hands, if not for ourselves, but for others.

The only people that fare well in the rat-race are the rats. The Company wanted us isolated because solidarity is contagious, and I know that we will prove this in the end. The fight for respect is difficult alone, but of course, it takes a village.



author

Jackie

Jackie, aged 20, is a hospitality worker and writer living in Glasgow. In 2026, they led Glasgow’s May Day march alongside their fellow striking workers.


Subscribe to Notes from Below

Subscribe now to Notes from Below, and get our print issues sent to your front door three times a year. For every subscriber, we’re also able to print a load of free copies to hand out in workplaces, neighbourhoods, prisons and picket lines. Can you subscribe now and support us in spreading Marxist ideas in the workplace?